Best B&B we’ve ever stayed in!
Beautiful, spotless, quiet & homey with perfect breakfasts: Donna-Lee & Matt have thought of everything to make a stay just exceptional.
Located just outside the Main Street and shops of NOTL, this B&B is on a quiet side street. We visited on a cool weekend and chose to drive but on a sunnier day it would be a nice walk downtown. From the moment you come in and are warmly greeted, the owners make you feel both at home and respect your privacy. The home is set up so you have your own entrance from the main vestibule with passcode entry. The suite had everything we needed – even an extra toothbrush, which we had to take advantage of. And the little touches made the stay very special. We even got a little Halloween treat left for us!! For anyone worried about COVID- this was set up perfectly. Even the little table in the suite was set up to have a private in room breakfast delivered to our door. The breakfasts themselves were just delicious. Perfectly prepared, the bacon on the side was what all the other reviewers said- “the best bacon ever”! We definitely can’t wait to come back here!!

Nov 2020

Beautiful B&B in Prime Location
I stayed 2 nights at Butler Creek House while visiting family. Matt and Donna Lee are friendly and generous hosts who go above and beyond for their guests and are great conversationalists. The rooms are spacious, spotless, and the bed was very cozy. The bathroom and suite includes everything you could ever need to be comfortable, including toiletries, plenty of towels, robes, a selection of tea, a kettle, and coffee maker in room. Donna Lee puts a lot of thought into the presentation and decor of the rooms and her breakfast plans–best fruit salad I’ve ever had! The setting is ideal–the B&B is located on a quiet dead end street and is within walking distance or a short drive to downtown. Ive stayed in a couple B&Bs in Niagara-on-the-Lake and this is my favourite by far!

Oct 2020

Long Weekend in NOTL
Just to say a big thank you to our hosts and owners Matt & Donna Lee for a wonderful stay at the Butler Creek House.
We cant speak highly enough about the place, everything was just perfect, room, hosts, service, breakfast help & advice.
After day one we were already planning our next trip to stay at the Butler Creek House need we say more. We sincerely hope that during these testing times that Matt & Donna Lee manage to weather the storm and stay open.
Steve & Sherry

Sep 2020

A wee gem in NOTL
Decided to have a girls wine weekend in NOTL, and came across this little gem. Donna Lee and Matt are amazing hosts, they made us feel like we were visiting family! The room was really clean and spacious, and the COVID precautions in place evident and appreciated. Breakfast was great, Donna Lee is an amazing cook! Would 100% recommend Butler Creek House to anyone staying in NOTL, we will be going back there again for sure!
Tracy & Alex

Sep 2020

Amazing Spot
We had to cancel our wedding day due to Covid, so my fiancé and I decided to go on a little trip to Niagara On the Lake for a wine tour. We would’ve never expected the highlight of the trip to be the B&B. Matt and Donna are the best. M’lady and I have zero bad things to say about our stay there. The breakfasts were amazing, the room was very spacious, the bed was comfortable, Matt and Donna were so personable and easy to chat with, and even the people we met who were also staying at the B&B were awesome. We both give the Butler Creek House a 10/10 and will definitely be coming back soon.

Sep 2020

Like family
Donna Lee and Matt are amazing hosts, they made us feel like we were visiting family! The room was really clean and spacious, and the COVID precautions in place evident and appreciated. Breakfast was great, Donna Lee is an amazing cook! Would 100% recommend Butler Creek House to anyone staying in NOTL, we will be going back there again for sure!

Sep 2020

Everything you could want and need

Donna Lee and Matt were truly gracious hosts. The breakfasts were delicious with good portions – fruit salad & yogurt + french toast with maple bacon was our favourite. The Grand Georgian Suite is beautiful, and spotless which took care of our COVID concerns. The room is a great size and also comes with a side room – we felt like royalty. Netflix + Spotify on two tvs and the jacuzzi bath tub were useful touches as well. Awesome place! Photos don’t do it justice.


Aug 2020

Memorable experience in NOTL
We spent a few nights here at the Butler Creek House and it was epic and memorable thanks to our gracious hosts, Matt & Donna Lee. They went above and beyond to ensure we had a great time and we certainly did. The location is perfect where you can go on an adventurous nature walk, adjacent to their beautiful B&B, where we spotted fireflies in the forest. There are also nearby places to eat that are conveniently in walking distance. The rooms were very clean and cozy. The food was delicious and we appreciated eating the local organic fruits for breakfast. We highly recommend this place run by amazing people 🙂

July 2020

A real gem

What a great spot! Donna and Matt are wonderful hosts and are up to the banter at the breakfast table. Highly recommend this property.


Feb 2020

Surpasses all expectations
Had one great night there in May. Matt and Donna Lee are warm, interesting, and fun hosts but give you space. The house is restored and gorgeous, the large rooms and grounds adjacent to the creek are lovely. Coffee, teas and fridge in the privacy of our room, then breakfast at 9 was perfect. And 420 friendly.

May 2019

Super Hosts!

Highly recommend this B&B! Cozy, comfortable and relaxing with super hosts! They were very accommodating and made us feel right at home. Breakfast was absolutely delicious and they even made sure it met everyone’s dietary needs! Thanks again for having us!


May 2019

Travellers to Travellers

Donna Lee and Matt are fantastic hosts- friendly, interesting, interested, well travelled, helpful…. and the breakfasts are excellent!!


May 2019

Wine Country

Butler Creek House is great B&B. The location is close enough to the old town to be walking distance and is near to a couple wineries to boot. The B&B itself is well-kept, cozy, and clean. Both the hosts are wonderful and accommodating, they’ll go out of their way to ensure you have a smooth and enjoyable stay.


April 2019

Book Here!

If you’re looking for a B&B, stop looking and book here. Matt and Donna are amazing hosts. The property is beautiful, rooms are immaculate and breakfast is delicious (make sure not to fill up on the freshly baked banana bread – it will be hard though). Looking forward to coming back again very soon!


March 2019

Great place Great people
Just fabulous. Mid range price ,luxury amenities and services. Really enjoyed our stay wish it could have been longer. The cold -20/30 was only out done by the warmth of our welcome,extreamly comfortable room and hospitality of our hosts Matt and Donna…thank you both.

February 2019

Great Place to Stay
My husband and I really enjoyed our stay at the Butler Creek House. The breakfasts were sumptuous-lots of fresh fruit, lovely pastries, French toast, eggs, maple glazed bacon, juice, jams, etc., attractively served in a comfortable room with lots of natural light, with plants and many interesting artifacts as a backdrop. Our room was tastefully decorated, the bed was comfortable, linens and towels were clean, the bathroom was spotless. We appreciated the little extra touches like the mini-chocolates in our room, and extra toiletries in the bathroom. The house is in a good location with easy access to wineries and eating places, but sufficiently off the beaten path so that we were able to enjoy our nature walk on a path just a short distance outside our front door. We enjoyed our hosts Matt and Donna Lee. They made us feel like welcome guests in the home of friends with their attention to every detail for our comfort, their suggestions about eating places and most of all their warmth and good conversation.

January 2019

Matt and Donna are the most amazing hosts! They were so friendly and welcoming. They were so helpful with every part of our visit. The rooms and amenities are incredible and clean. The breakfast was delicious and the have the best BACON ever! We look forward to going back and staying at the Butler Creek house! Thank you Matt and Donna for an incredible stay!

January 2019

Matt and Donna are wonderful and welcoming hosts! They have a wealth of knowledge and are helpful in enriching your stay by providing local information of things to do. My husband and I loved the Garden Balcony Suite and the vast amenities. We enjoyed watching Netflix in the large sitting room. The bedroom has a fireplace that creates a romantic atmosphere. The bed is extremely comfortable and the balcony is fantastic to enjoy your cup of tea. You will be mesmerized by the beautiful gardens and backyard. The location is ideal for shopping nearby and its a short walking distance to delightful restaurants. The breakfast is delicious! We felt pampered for the duration of our stay! We definitely will be back!!!!
Bonnie & Mike

December 2018

Could not have been better!
Lovely home with every convenience. Breakfast was delicious and varied every day. Our hosts could not have been nicer and did every thing possible to make our visit worry free. A very convenient location. Would highly recommend and would definitely go back.

December 2018

Great time at Butler Creek House
My wife and I were staying in Niagara on the Lake for a wedding. We ended up choosing Butler Creek House for our accommodation and it was a fantastic choice. Matt and Donna were very knowledgeable, approachable hosts and just great people. The room that we stayed in (Balcony room) was very nice, the breakfast was delicious and they even offered up a hat and scarf for when I decided to go out for a walk on a brisk morning. I would highly recommend staying at this B&B if you are in the area.

November 2018

Donna and Matt were very hospitable hosts. Breakfast was very good. Since my husband enjoys a more simple breakfast, Donna made bacon and eggs for him and a wonderful quiche for the rest of us. They offered helpful info about the area and were very interesting to talk with. We enjoyed the Grand Georgian Suite. It was comfortable, clean, and had plenty of room.
Jeanette & Phill

Ooctober 2018

Fantastic B&B
What a treasure Butler Creek House is. Donna Lee and Matt were so welcoming and friendly. Thanks to Donna Lee for telling us about the local food truck evening – food and entertainment great! The Georgian Suite was beautiful, lovely furnishings and comfortable beds and the personal touches made it so welcoming. Breakfasts were incredible – especially the care taken with mine as I am a celiac. This is the best b&b we have ever stayed in. Such a relaxed atmosphere it felt like being in your own home. Donna Lee and Matt went out of their way to take care of my wife who arrived feeling unwell.
Iain, Linda & Sara

September 2018

Donna Lee and Matt were wonderful hosts. The accommodations were on the north end of wonderful. This was our first experience with a B & B. We were there for two nights. The room was comfortable and the bathroom was outstanding with modern fixtures. The breakfasts were excellent and very healthy with local fruits and fresh baked items. We can’t imagine any place that would be better. This stay exceeded our expectations in every way. We are already planning a trip back. – Russ and Yvonne Allen
Russ & Yvonne

August 2018

Outstanding Stay at Butler Creek House!
We stayed at the Butler Creek House for two nights in late July. Donna Lee and Matt are marvelous hosts and couldn’t have been more engaging and accommodating. Their home is lovely and the breakfasts were fabulous. Each one started with a delicious fresh fruit salad, warm, freshly-baked cake and/or croissants followed by the main course (French toast and bacon one day and quiche and bacon the next), orange juice and plenty of coffee…a perfect start to our day. The first day we were there, I mentioned to Donna Lee that I loved peaches…when we returned to the B&B that evening, a bowl of fresh peaches were strategically placed in the foyer to greet us! So thoughtful and amazing! The bedrooms are spacious and include everything one could need for a comfortable stay (coffee and tea for early risers along with TV, iron and ironing board, travel books, etc)…along with nice chocolates and water! They also have a beautiful outdoor seating area for the guests to use and fluffy robes and slippers!. I would highly recommend the BCH for a memorable and relaxing stay in NOTL.
PGH Travellers

August 2018

More than happy with the experience we had at this B&B. It is unique, Matt and Donna are not just ‘the owners’, they are the best hosts we have ever met. If you are considering going to this place, don’t hesitate, make your reservation and enjoy this beautiful second home.
Andrea & Kevin

July 2018

A Delight
Disclaimer: first of all let me say that the hosts of Butler Creek House, Matt and Donna Lee, are my friends. But the comfort and beauty of this gorgeous B&B outweighs any bias I may have. They invited me to stay one night. I had the balcony room. A great place. Modern, clean, bright, comfortable. Close to the heart of Niagara-on-theLake. Oh, and the breakfast…Perfect. 5 stars.

July 2018

Amazing weekend at Butler Creek House in Niagara on the Lake
My two adult children and I just had an amazing weekend in Niagara on the Lake. We stayed at Butler Creek House in the Grand Georgian Suite which had a queen size bed, a sitting room with a pull-out sofa and an ensuite bathroom with a whirlpool tub. The suite was easily able to accommodate the 3 of us and was furnished beautifully with antique furniture and bedding. It was also air conditioned – very important for the +30 degree weather when we were there! We were pleased to see all the little extras for our convenience: wine glasses, coffee maker, mugs, tea etc. as well as shampoo, extra toothbrush and toothpaste if required. It immediately felt like a home away from home. And that was just the beginning! We went downstairs for breakfast the next morning and had a superb breakfast (made daily by our hosts) that started with a fresh fruit salad and croissants followed by bacon and homemade quiche, and of course fresh coffee. Every day we had a different menu. Our food allergy was accommodated no problem, and there was a beautifully set table where we sat with the other guests and were free to linger. It was a wonderful way to start the day. Our hosts, Donna and Matt, provided a wealth of information on area activities and the history of the Niagara region which kept us busy through the weekend. We rented bikes and did a self guided wine tour, and Matt and Donna provided information on hiking, jet-boating, the Shaw festival as well as the Canada Day celebrations and fireworks. Donna and Matt truly took it upon themselves to make sure we had a wonderful stay at their B&B and enjoyed ourselves in the Niagara area. It was a wonderful weekend family getaway from Toronto.

July 2018

Fabulous getaway
My wife and I just returned home from a very enjoyable two night stay at the Butler Creek House. Matt and Donna Lee were the perfect hosts and they accommodated my wife’s lactose intolerance needs for the delicious breakfasts served. We were in Niagara on the Lake for an historical event and it was great to meet fellow guests who were also there for the same reason. While Butler Creek House is a bit of a walk to the Old Town, we didn’t mind as it is situated on a quiet residential street with a lovely conservation area nearby.The suite we occupied was very clean and spacious with a comfortable large double bed, a sitting room where tea and coffee were provided along with a fridge and utensils. The bathroom was fabulous with a great shower. There were plenty of linens and the bathroom was extremely clean and well supplied. All of this made for a fabulous stay. One of our best B&B experiences ever. We wouldn’t hesitate to stay there again and we would highly recommend Butler Creek House for an amazing getaway. Superb! Thank you Matt and Donna Lee for a most enjoyable time and for beind such graxious hosts.

June 2018

Three Old Friends Now Have a Great Getaway!
My friends and I have been taking a short summer trip for about 15 years now, and Butler Creek House was by far the best accommodations we have ever had. Matt and Donna Lee were gracious hosts with plenty of tips on what to do in the area. Breakfasts were wonderful and so were the rooms. I am certain we will come again and recommend this B&B to anyone.
Aimee & Cathy & Rose

June 2018

Great Place to Stay
My husband and I spent 2 nights at Butler Creek House on our first trip to Niagara on the Lake. While many of our B & B experiences have been in Victorian style homes, Butler Creek is a more contemporary and airy home in a residential neighborhood, with excellent access to the historic downtown. The rooms are large and beautifully furnished. Liked the comfortable furnishings and access to great backyard deck and large hot tub. It is located in a quiet neighborhood close to everything: bike rental and paths, downtown and theater, nice restaurants, walking paths. The hosts, Donna Lee and Matt, are engaging, helpful and dedicated to their guests comfort. We enjoyed our delicious, multi-course breakfasts. Donna Lee even gave us water and wonderful homebaked cookies for our drive home, while Matt provided excellent suggestions for eating and biking.

June 2018

Amazing Getaway!!
This has been the most amazing stay my Wife and I have had at a B&B, Inn, Hotel or anywhere for that matter! The room we had was large and spotlessly clean with a beautiful shower and in-room amenities like coffee maker and fridge. Breakfast was delicious and presented in a matter befitting a five star restaurant. Donna Lee and Matt both made us feel like long lost friends. This is a stay we will be making again for sure and I’d recommend it to anybody.
Pam & Carl

May 2018

Best B&B in Niagara-on-the-Lake
This is the nicest B&B my husband and I have been to in Niagara. The rooms are huge and freshly decorated. Robes and slippers, chocolate and amenities were waiting when we arrived. The bed was so comfortable. Free WIFI. Breakfast was a feast. And the hosts Matt and Donna Lee couldn’t be nicer and more accommodating.
Erica & Terry

May 2018

A beautiful B&B
Thank you both so much for the wonderful care and the beautiful accommodations! Much luck to you in the future! Have a wonderful summer!
Renee & Joe

May 2018

Lovely and inviting house
We had a newly remodeled room and our own sitting room with an enormous bathroom. Everything was beautifully decorated and very clean. Our hosts were warm and friendly and made us feel as though we were visiting a friend’s house. There was a fridge and coffee/tea pots in the room, as well as an electric fireplace which we used because it was cold during our trip. There is a walking trail right outside the door, the neighborhood was quiet and pretty. We highly recommend this B&B.

April 2018

Easter getaway
It was a short trip for me and my girlfriend over Easter. We spent a day and a night at the Butler Creek House. The hosts were great. We received a warm welcome from both of them, they are genuine great people and they made us feel right at home, like we were visiting long time friends. The room was beautiful, very cozy and nicely decorated. The bedding, shams, pillows, the covers all perfectly arranged. To top it all there is a sitting area, fridge, wine glasses and wine opener available. We were out exploring the enchanting town and came back at night to unwind in the warm outdoor jacuzzi that is available in the backyard. You do not want to miss the breakfast, also included!, everything is fresh and delicious. We definitely recommend staying at the Butler Creek House and will stay here next time we come back to Niagara at the lake.

April 2018

Wonderful B & B
This was our first B&B and we were not sure what to expect. We were made to feel welcome right away and loved our room. The bedrooms have their own sitting rooms with mini fridge and coffee maker with all you need to make a great cup of coffee. We had plans for the evening then returned later for a most wonderful and peacefully quiet sleep. Breakfast was fresh made goodness! Mmmm homemade croissants….. We had a wonderful time and thoroughly enjoyed everything. We will be returning!
Sandra & Cam

April 2018

Relaxing, Comfortable and Friendly

Butler Creek House can be described as cozy, friendly and welcoming. It is located in a residential, quieter part of town but within walking distance of the great restaurants and shops. The breakfast was delicious on both of the days we stayed. The hosts Donna Lee and Matt clearly enjoy running their business as evidenced by the extra care they show to make sure their guests have every comfort. They are themselves well traveled. We found this to be an added bonus because they have interesting stories and decorative features that they found during their trips. I would recommend this B & B to anyone who is looking for a friendly relaxing place to stay,

Celeste & Klaus

April 2018

Amazing time
We had such a lovely and wonderful time at the house: beautiful and big room with our private living room, great breakfast and warm hosts. I would highly recommend this place and I am planning to go back for sure.

March 2018

B&B Believers Now
My husband & I came to NOTL for the weekend just for a getaway. We had never stayed at a B&B before so weren’t sure what to expect. Our stay far exceeded anything we could have thought. Donna Lee & Matt are awesome hosts!!! They went out of their way to make us feel comfortable & at home during our stay. The breakfasts were amazing, and they were very accommodating to our gluten intolerances!! Our room was very nice, great bed (hard to find!), and the sitting room was very convenient as I get up much earlier than my spouse so it was great to have a place to sit & read or watch tv until he got up. We like to walk, and it was not very far of a walk at all to get to Old town….maybe 10-15 minutes. We couldn’t stop talking about our stay & said we felt like we had just been visiting a friend’s house, that’s how good of a time we had. We definitely enjoyed our first B&B experience and can guarantee we would stay here again provided the availability was there when we were planning to come. Heck, we might even plan our stay around their availability!
Amy & Josh

March 2018

A Home Away From Home
This is a first class accommodation. The room was stunning and the amenities are a touch of class. Matt and Donna Lee are exceptional hosts, friendly as they bring you into the conversation and as a result you feel you are a friend. Go and enjoy yourself.
Ray & Karen

March 2018

Great Weekend at Butler Creek House
My wife and I spent 2 nights at the house as a delayed Valentines getaway. We have stayed over in town on several occasions but this was our first stay at the Butler Creek House. It was delightful. Donna Lee and Matt were very friendly and welcoming. They are in the middle of a renovation but whatever they are doing they do when guests are not there. Our room still had the old style but it was still very nice but I look forward to seeing the changes they will make on another visit. The room had a large sitting room attached and an electric fireplace in the bedroom. The location is just outside of the main village center which is good because it’s a quiet street up against a small woods. Town main street is a 2 minute drive away. The breakfast was overwhelming and great! We look forward to another visit!
Randy & Heidi

March 2018

Night in NOTL
First experience at a B&B and in NOTL. We stayed at Butler Creek for one night. Beautiful house, great room with comfortable bed and spacious sitting area-coffee maker, mini fridge and everything you need to be comfortable. The room was private and very clean and the hosts were exceptional, we were greeted with a warm welcome, easy check in and Matt and Donna Lee were great hosts, not intrusive at all and very laid back–breakfast in the morning was delicious-the quiche was awesome!! Will definitely stay here again. Thanks Matt and Donna Lee for a great experience!
Mike & Mel

March 2018

Girls Weekend in Wine Country 🙂
We had a group of 5 ladies share two rooms at the B&B, complete with a living room/lounging room, big bathrooms, plenty of space to move around, drink wine and enjoy each others company with out feeling cramped. A comfortable environment and more equipped than expected with towels, robes, toiletries, hair dryer, coffee maker, mini fridge, etc. We definitely enjoyed the delicious breakfasts too! All in all a very enjoyable experience and very close to local wineries and restaurants on the strip.

March 2018

Amazing atmosphere!
Spent the weekend at Butler Creek House and it was perfect. Relaxed atmosphere, beautiful area and exceptional rooms all made for a great experience. The owners made us feel very welcome. Cannot wait to go back!
Todd F

February 2018


My boyfriend and I stayed at Butler Creek House for the night on Valentine’s Day. The owners were amazing, super welcoming and made you feel right at home. And the house was absolutely beautiful, very cute and cozy. We will definitely come back again! Would absolutely recommend to all.


February 2018

Great getaway
We stayed at Butler Creek House as part of a weekend getaway in Niagara on the Lake. It was the perfect pairing to our exploring and wineries. Very comfortable, attractive and charming and breakfast was perfect! It is really well located for heading out on foot or by car. Our hosts were professional, interesting very welcoming! We would go back again for sure, and highly recommend it to others.

February 2018

Perfect stay
We spent part of the long weekend at Butler Creek House, and loved it. The room was spacious and very well appointed. The en suite washroom was fantastic. DL and Matt the proprietors were very friendly and most helpful. This is a perfect location to see the area from. Wine tour operators will pick you up right from the house. DL’s breakfast was delicious and plentiful. We would highly recommend staying here. Great value for a lovely room. We hope to be back again!
John M

February 2018

Recently went for a two night stay at Butler Creek. What a beautiful bed and breakfast. The rooms are so spacious and have private sitting rooms. TVs in bedrooms and sitting rooms. Access to Wifi too. The hosts Matt and DL were fantastic, really nice people. The food was excellent, lots of choice and exceptional quality. This is a place that is so worth going to you will not be disappointed. I will be going there again for sure as it had everything we wanted and more.
Mike S

February 2018

Wonder FRESH fruit Bowl

Donna Lee and Matt are wonderful hostess and host. The setting is a quiet street and the space is more like an apartment. A large bedroom with fireplace, a sitting room with two sofas, and a very large bath with huge tub and separate shower. While the room was very nice, breakfast was wonderful. A large bowl of just prepared fruit, just baked croissants, farm fresh eggs, and bacon (Canadian style). The bonus for a B&B is the personality of the hostess and host. Enjoyable chats that are engaging and have you thinking about a return trip.

Roger P

January 29, 2018

Lovely New Years Eve spent at the Butler Creek House

We stayed 1 night at the Butler creek House. The room was a suite with Large bedroom , separate sitting room and enormous bathroom with a whirlpool tub and separate shower. the rooms were bright and airy, white bathrobes and slippers were supplied. The room had lots of amenities: fridge, glasses, wine opener, coffee and tea and hot chocolate with real mugs, chocolates, 2 t.v.s., books and of course wifi. Breakfast was delicious with several choices available. We had French toast and pancakes as well as yogurt and fruit, freshly made carrot muffins and juice. We hope to return in the spring to be able to use the nearby walking trails and see the renovations that are in the works. Situated within walking distance to downtown Niagara on the Lake at the end of a quiet street.

Susan S

January 1, 2018

New Year’s Eve

This is a great place. Donna-Lee and Matt are really nice people and very friendly. The B&B was very clean, in great shape, and full of all the amenities you could need. I would definitely recommend this place.


January 2018

Great quiet spot for basing a trip to NOTL
My wife Jane and I had a great time here. We visited for three nights during late September, 2017. Donna Lee and Matt are wonderful hosts. The breakfasts were scrumptious, and the room was very spacious, beautiful and well maintained. We had some wonderful meals at some of the local restaurants that Matt had recommended. We visited many of the local wineries, and made excursions to Niagara Falls, Fort George and St. Catharines Museum & Canals Centre, as well as the local downtown area. Butler Creek House was a great base for our stay. We especially enjoyed the sitting room in our suite, for winding down at the end of a day.
Steve & Jane

September 2017